• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Bella Sorella Pizza: Authentic Wood-Fired Pizza & Italian Flavors in Clayton, OH

Bella Sorella Pizza in Clayton, OH, delivers authentic wood-fired pizzas with a genuine Italian touch. Their menu shines with standout dishes like the next-level meatballs and fresh, vibrant salads. The atmosphere transports you to Italy, enhanced by attentive service and a clean, inviting space. Guests rave about unique offerings such as the Greek pizza and generous salads, while desserts like tiramisu and cannoli provide a perfect finish. Whether dining on the patio or inside, Bella Sorella combines quality ingredients with warm hospitality, making every visit feel like a special occasion. It’s a must-try for pizza lovers seeking flavor and charm.

Bella Sorella Pizza at a glance

  • Address 1405 Esther Price Wy, Clayton, OH 45315, United States
  • Phone +1 937-503-3482
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant .

Photos & Gallery

Bella Sorella Pizza: Reviews & Ratings

Eric Mueller
5

If you're looking for authentic wood-fired pizza, this is your new go-to. The pizza is fantastic, but do yourself a favor and order the meatballs—they're truly next-level. Paired with one of their fresh salads, it's the perfect meal. You won't be disappointed!

CAM
5

I highly recommend Bella Sorella. They're still in their first days and I am impressed at how well this establishment is ran. The food is good. It's clean. And while it was our first visit, we felt like family. I recommend trying the meatballs and calamari. I'm generally not a fan of pizza, but the Greek pizza is worth your time. I'm already looking forward to our next visit.

Heather Brown
5

Walked in at 6pm for a party of 14 and was able to sit down in less than 10 mins. The food and atmosphere felt like we could have been in Italy. Our server was so attentive and got all our orders correct and food came out in perfect timings. Definitely will be back.

Steven Bissey
5

Well, decided to try the new pizza jloint. It was early on a Sat eve so not crowded at all. Reagan was great! The two of us shared a Cesar's salad. It was super, plenty for two, big crusty croutons and ample dressing. Would of liked some olives, but well?? Our pizza was Bella Deluxe. It was great, you can't beat a wood fired pizza crust. I like a little more sauce and the toppings were pretty skimpy for a 12" pizza that was $18. But it was really good. I will go back and try another pizza next time. Really wish they had wine too.

Ashley Parrett
5

I’ve been to Bella Sorella twice. The first time my family sat on the patio on a beautiful fall day. I had The Queen, my husband had The Big Truck and my daughter had Mia Maria. All were delicious. We especially loved The Big Truck. The second time we came was for my sister’s birthday and we had a group of 9 on a Friday night and they did a great job accommodating us. This time we shared The Big Truck and focused on desserts. We tried the Tiramisu, Cannoli and Merengue. I’m a big fan of Tiramisu and theirs was the best I’ve ever had! I loved that they had a TV on playing an old movie. This place has a very clean atmosphere and just a really cool vibe. I’ll definitely be back.

Will T
4

If you need some delicious authentic pizza and the Englewood Clayton area this is the place to go. The tiramisu was very good as well and the ladyfingers were soaked correctly. The atmosphere is new and the restaurant is as well, the lack of Italian music was a little odd for the atmosphere but not too bad. The pizza is absolutely amazing

John Wallace
5

First time being able to dine in given the big crowds since opening. The food did not disappoint! My wife and I had been eyeing the queen pizza and meatballs for weeks. Both were delicious! The German lager draft also paired well with the pizza. Friendly welcome from the hostess and the service was great as well! We got some canollis to go and they looked amazing! Can't wait to go back!

Location

  • Bella Sorella Pizza
    Bella Sorella Pizza
    1405 Esther Price Wy, Clayton, OH 45315, United States Hotline: +1 937-503-3482

Located in the heart of Clayton, Ohio, Bella Sorella Pizza invites pizza lovers to experience authentic wood-fired flavors crafted with care and passion. From the moment you step inside, the atmosphere effortlessly transports you to Italy, offering a warm, inviting space perfect for family dinners or celebrations. The key highlight here is their expertly baked pizzas, boasting a crisp, smoky crust that serves as a perfect canvas for fresh, thoughtfully chosen toppings.

One cannot talk about Bella Sorella without mentioning their standout meatballs—praised by patrons for being truly next-level. These savory delights, paired with their fresh, vibrant salads, create a well-rounded, satisfying meal that keeps guests coming back. The menu is thoughtfully diverse; unique offerings like the Greek pizza provide an adventurous twist for those seeking something beyond the classic pie.

The service matches the quality of the food, with attentive staff ensuring smooth, personalized dining experiences even for larger groups. The family-friendly vibe and spotless setting elevate your visit, while the inclusion of nostalgic touches, like classic movies playing on TV, add to the charm.

Dessert lovers will find joy in Bella Sorella’s offerings like tiramisu and cannoli, which have been described as some of the best around—light, creamy, and perfectly balanced against the savory main courses. Whether enjoying a casual weekday meal or celebrating a special occasion, Bella Sorella Pizza delivers an authentic taste of Italy with a welcoming ambiance that never disappoints.

Business Information

  • Service options
    • Delivery